Sugar Creek Homes with Unfinished Basement

Sugar Creek Homes with Unfinished Basement

Welcome to Sugar Creek, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of New Palestine, Indiana, within Hancock County. This charming community is known for its picturesque landscapes, friendly atmosphere, and a strong sense of belonging. Sugar Creek offers a perfect blend of suburban tranquility and convenient access to urban amenities, making it an ideal place for families, retirees, and anyone seeking a peaceful lifestyle.

One of the standout features of homes in this region is the availability of properties with unfinished basements. These versatile spaces present endless possibilities for homeowners looking to customize their living environments. Imagine transforming that blank canvas into a cozy family room, a home gym, or even a stylish entertainment area! The unfinished basements provide the opportunity to add personal touches that reflect your unique style and needs.

Sugar Creek is not just about beautiful homes; it’s also about community. With nearby parks, recreational facilities, and excellent schools, residents enjoy a vibrant lifestyle filled with outdoor activities and social events. The friendly neighbors and community spirit make it easy to feel at home, while the convenient location offers quick access to nearby Indianapolis for those seeking a taste of city life.

Whether you’re looking to invest in a property with potential or simply searching for a welcoming community to call home, Sugar Creek in New Palestine is a delightful choice. Embrace the charm of this lovely region and discover the endless possibilities that await in homes with unfinished basements. Your dream home is just a visit away!

Newest Sugar Creek Homes with Unfinished Basement

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Welcome to your completely updated home with 42'x59' heated shop on over half an acre in the heart of Thorntown! A charming, newly completed cedar-wrapped porch leads inside to welcoming front foyer or dining room boasting new modern light fixture, LVP flooring and fresh paint. The large living room features a brick hearth fireplace and a pass-through to your incredibly updated new kitchen. This chef's kitchen boasts stainless steel appliances, subway tiled backsplash, quartz countertops, abundant cabinetry, and a cozy breakfast nook. Don't miss the huge pantry/laundry room complete with loads of storage. The main floor primary suite serves as a serene retreat with fresh carpet, large walk-in closet and an amazing ensuite bath showcasing a double vanity and a custom tiled tub/shower combo. The main level also hosts a second fully updated bathroom with tiled tub/shower surround, new fixtures and quartz topped vanity. Upstairs, a flexible loft area opens up endless possibilities for a home library, playroom or office, accompanying 2 additional updated bedrooms. Walk through to the flex room off the second bedroom to find you third fully remodeled bathroom. Outside, the standout feature of this property is the nearly 2500sf heated shop complete with dual pass through overhead doors, an air compressor system, floor drains, integrated steel/wood workbenches, and electric doors, making it the ultimate dream shop, garage, or workshop space. Combined with a large, open backyard, new central air conditioning, and a prime location walkable to local shops, dining and parks, this property has it all! Come see it today!

605 W Main, Thorntown

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Indpls Metro N.

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Here is your chance to escape to the country! This 2 bedroom, 1.5 bath Bedford stone ranch offers a full unfinished basement that is bone dry, perfect for finishing. Much of the original character of the home remains preserved. The formal living room offers wood burning fireplace with stone front and built-in bookshelves, original hardwood flooring in great condition for refinishing, and large picture window to enjoy the beauty of the country side. The eat-in kitchen offers knotty pine walls and cabinetry, with retro countertops and tile backsplash still intact. Both bedrooms offer hardwood flooring and nice sized closets. The full bathroom offers a bathtub with shower surround, and updated vanity. There is a powder bath down the hall for guest use. 27x11 sunroom at the rear of the home offers wood stove for use during the cooler months. Oversized 1 car attached garage is fully finished with heating and cooling, could be possible to convert to a 3rd bedroom if needed. The basement has a framed family room space with woodburning fireplace. 30x27 blank space perfect for rec rm. Utility room with sump pit. The home sits on 1.2 acres of ground, with over 1,200sqft of heated detached garage space PLUS 15x11 workshop with electricity on opposite end of the property. Roof new in 2026! Rural living at its finest with no neighbors on any side of the home. Homes like this are hard to come by, don't miss your chance to say goodbye to city living!

3608 N London Road, Fairland

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Indy Metro Partners.

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Charming 11/2-story home situated on approximately 3.20 acres in West Terre Haute. This sale includes three parcels of land, offering plenty of space and potential. The property features a cistern and is located within the Vigo County School Corporation, serving Sugar Creek Consolidated Elementary School, West Vigo Middle School, and West Vigo High School. Property is being sold with no warranties or guarantees, expressed or implied.

5685 Darwin Road, West Terre Haute

Listing courtesy of L.J. Michaels, Inc..

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Welcome home to this charming and thoughtfully designed property offering comfort, character, and an outdoor space you'll never want to leave. The main level features spacious bedrooms connected by a convenient Jack-and-Jill bathroom, creating both functionality and privacy. Upstairs, the stunning primary suite feels like a true retreat with its beautiful vanity area, relaxing soaking tub, and peaceful atmosphere. Step outside to your own personal oasis - a fully fenced backyard perfect for entertaining, pets, or quiet evenings at home, all leading to the detached 2-car garage. This home blends warmth, charm, and everyday comfort both inside and out.

311 S B Street, Thorntown

Listing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway Home.

5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths

Proposed Build by Joyner Homes - The Timber Escape on Lot 2 (1.5 Acres). Welcome to Rockfield Estates in the New Palestine School System, a custom neighborhood featuring 1.5 to 2.0 acre lots designed for space, privacy, and community living. This proposed build offers 3,008 square feet with 5 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, and a 3-car garage. The home is designed with an open-concept floor plan highlighted by a two-story great room, vaulted ceilings in the Owner's Suite, Veranda, Screened Porch, and Great Room, 9-foot ceilings on the main level, 8-foot ceilings upstairs, and built-in mudroom cubbies for everyday organization. The main floor includes a spacious kitchen with center island and pantry, dining nook, laundry, mudroom, and an Owner's Suite with private bath and walk-in closet. Upstairs features additional bedrooms, a loft with balcony overlook, and open views to the main level. Buyers have the opportunity to personalize their home with optional upgrades such as a screened porch or veranda, hearth room fireplace, patio or grill porch, bonus room above the garage, and built-in laundry enhancements. Rockfield Estates combines the charm of country living with the conveniences of suburban life, all within the highly sought-after New Palestine Schools. Plus, the neighborhood will soon have access to the Pennsy Trail, connecting you to miles of scenic walking, running, and biking paths. At Joyner Homes' Design Studio, you can customize finishes, materials, and selections to make this Timber Escape uniquely yours. Rockfield Estates 3600 W 100 S, Greenfield, IN 46140

Lot 2 Jericho West Court, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Daniels Real Estate.

Start Your Search

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative

Karen Parker

Karen Parker is an established real estate broker with United Real Estate, located at 1425 E. 86th Street, Suite 200, Indianapolis, IN 46240. As a trusted local expert, Karen brings extensive knowledge of the Indianapolis market and a deep understanding of what it takes to successfully buy and sell real estate in this area. Real estate is not the same everywhere, and her clients value her up-to-date market insight, strategic guidance, and commitment to delivering results. Karen is passionate about serving buyers and sellers throughout the Indianapolis area, providing honest advice, clear communication, and a personalized approach every step of the way. Outside of real estate, Karen enjoys exploring local parks and walking trails near her home in Indianapolis. She loves spending time at home with her husband, who is preparing for retirement, as they enter the exciting season of becoming nearly empty nesters. In her downtime, Karen enjoys reading, gardening, and watching Garden Answer and Survivor. Originally from Washington State, Karen was born and raised on the Colville Indian Reservation and is the sixth of nine children. She is a proud mother of three—two in the workforce and one currently in college—and a devoted grandmother to two beautiful grandchildren.

Learn More